Reviews went live on November 18, the day before launch, and Grand Theft Auto VI went straight to the top of the charts. Both aggregators settled on 99, which Bloomberg called the best-reviewed video game ever — level with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time on Metacritic.
The aggregate scores
- Metacritic (PS5): 99 from roughly 150 critics, with no mixed or negative reviews. Metacritic
- OpenCritic: 99 top-critic average from 89 reviews, 99% recommend. OpenCritic
- Early snapshots moved between 98 and 99 as more reviews came in. Bloomberg
What the big outlets scored
- IGN — 10/10: the amount of detail in the world and the freedom to experiment. IGN
- GameSpot — 10/10: the density of small touches makes the long wait feel worth it. GameSpot
- Game Informer — 10/10. Game Informer
- Push Square — 10/10: the best open world yet, with rewarding heist planning and a more grown-up Jason and Lucia story; the 30fps cap is the one knock. Push Square
- Pure Xbox — 10/10: the most impressive open world the reviewer has played, with smarter police and deeper systems. Pure Xbox
- VGC — 5/5: a modern masterpiece with Rockstar's best leads; occasional frame drops in dense areas. VGC
- GamesRadar+ — 5/5: the new benchmark for open-world detail this generation. GamesRadar+
- TheGamer — 5/5: the series' best story and reworked core mechanics. TheGamer
- Eurogamer — 5/5. Eurogamer
- Kotaku (unscored): an open-world design masterpiece carried by the Jason and Lucia relationship; controls still feel clunky at times.
The few non-perfect scores
Noisy Pixel gave it 9/10, pointing at uneven pacing in the story and some performance dips. The New York Times was also reported at 9/10. Pure Xbox roundup
What keeps coming up
- Praise: the most detailed open world yet, Jason and Lucia as a duo, heist planning, a world that reacts to you, and smarter police.
- Criticism: 30 frames per second on every console (no performance mode), some clunky controls, and a slower story start.
Want to see it in motion first? The review videos from IGN, GameSpot and Digital Foundry are on our videos page.
